Kant’s Theory of Progress
My topic is Kant’s theory of historical progress. My approach is primarily textual and contextual. I analyse in some detail Kant’s three most important essays on the topic: ‘Idea for a Universal History’, the third part of ‘Theory and Practice’ and the second part of The Conflict of the Faculties. I devote particular attention to the Kant-Herder debate about progress, but also discuss Rousseau, Mendelssohn, Hegel and others. In presenting, on Kant’s behalf, a strong case for his theory of progress, I address the main objections which have been put to it. These are: (i) historical teleology is incoherent (history can’t have a goal because there is no intentional actor functioning at the historical level); (ii) historical teleology undermines morality (if things are getting better anyway, why do I have to try to make them better?); (iii) progress involves ‘chronological unfairness’ (if things are getting better, doesn’t this mean that earlier generations get a raw deal?); (iv) progress consigns the species to ‘spurious infinity’ (isn’t endless improvement endlessly unsatisfactory?); (v) progress amounts to pernicious homogenization (doesn’t the elimination of traditional practices and values
impoverish our world?); (vi) the idea of progress is just ‘secularized’ religion (and
should be rejected accordingly). In relation to (vi), I consider the Löwith-Blumenberg debate, and draw some general conclusions about the issue of ‘secularization’. In relating these to Kant, I argue for the
following position: (a) his theory of progress is more than merely secularized religion; (b) to the extent that it can be described in terms of the secularization thesis, this reflects his ‘critical’ endeavour to rationalize Christianity; (c) in any case, the idea of progress by no means exhausts the rational potential of religion, and so should not be seen as
intended to replace the latter.Kant
Item Type | Thesis (Doctoral) |
---|---|
Keywords | Kant, Historical Progress, Idea For A Universal History, Theory And Practice, The Conflict Of The Faculties, Herder, Rousseau, Mendelssohn, Hegel, Historical Teleology, Morality, Chronological Unfairness, Infinity, Homogenization, Religion, Secularization, Christianity |
Subjects | Philosophy |
Divisions | Institute of Philosophy |
Date Deposited | 08 Oct 2010 10:33 |
Last Modified | 05 Aug 2024 12:06 |
-
picture_as_pdf - PDFonline.pdf